Is Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub Still Available? – Full Ingredients, Price & Calories Guide

In 2026, the boundary between “Pizza Night” and “Sandwich Day” has officially blurred. Following a viral TikTok trend, Jimmy John’s launched a dedicated Toasted Pizza Sandwich platform that has quickly become a top seller. 

The Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub is a toasted-style sandwich made with Italian meats, provolone cheese, marinara-style sauce, and pizza-inspired seasonings. Prices typically range from $7.99 to $11.99, depending on size and location. It tastes like a portable pizza inside a sub roll.

We’ve tested both variations to bring you the full breakdown of flavors, ingredients, and 2026 value deals.

Does Jimmy John’s Still Have the Pizza Ssandwich in 2026?

The Pizza Sub is often a limited-time or regional menu item. Availability can vary by state and store.

If you don’t see it listed, you can often recreate it by customizing:

• An Italian sub
  
• Adding extra cheese
  
• Requesting marinara-style sauce (if available)
  
• Toasted option (if the location offers it)

Tip: Always check your local store’s current menu before visiting.

Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub Price (2026)

Prices vary by city, but generally fall within these ranges:

Prices may be slightly higher in major metro areas.

Value Tip: The Giant size is often more cost-effective per inch if you’re very hungry or sharing.

What Comes on a Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub?

The Pizza Sub is designed to deliver pizza flavor in sandwich form.

Typical Ingredients:

• Salami
  
• Pepperoni
  
• Capicola or Italian meats
  
• Provolone cheese
  
• Tomato-based pizza sauce
  
• Italian seasoning
  
• Fresh-baked sub roll
  

Some locations may offer:

• Toasted preparation
  
• Extra cheese
  
• Added vegetables
  

The combination creates a savory, cheesy, slightly tangy flavor profile similar to a classic pepperoni pizza.

The 2026 Pizza Sub Lineup

In 2026, we offer two distinct “Pizza Mode” experiences, both served on our fresh-baked French bread and toasted to activate a high-quality cheese pull.

The Toasted Sicilian Pizza Sandwich

This is the “Meat Lover’s” version of a pizza sub. It combines the zesty kick of our Italian meats with the comfort of a warm pizza.

• Ingredients: Hand-sliced Salami, Capocollo, and Ham.
• The “Pizza” Elements: Melted Mozzarella, signature Marinara sauce, and Oregano-Basil seasoning.
• Expert Review: It’s effectively a “Vito” that went to culinary school in Naples. The toasting process crisps the salami edges, making it much more savory than a cold sub.

The Toasted Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich

Perfect for vegetarians or cheese purists, this sub focuses on texture and the “triple-threat” of dairy.

• Ingredients: A blend of Mozzarella, Provolone, and Parmesan.
• The Finish: Smothered in Marinara and Oregano-Basil seasoning.
• Expert Review: The Parmesan provides a salty “bite” that balances the sweetness of the marinara.

2026 Nutritional Facts & Pricing

Because these subs are toasted and feature marinara and extra cheese, they are heartier than our standard “Originals.”

2026 Value Alert: Both pizza subs are eligible for the $1 Combo Upgrade through March 2026. You can add Kickin’ Ranch Chips and a drink for just $1.00 extra, making this a massive meal for under $13.

“Pro” Customization Hacks

To make your 2026 pizza sub truly “Freaky Fresh,” try these modifications:

1. The “Pepperoni” Hack: While we don’t carry traditional pepperoni, adding Extra Salami to the Sicilian Pizza Sandwich and toasting it creates a very similar spicy, crispy profile.
2. The Spicy Sicilian: Add Jimmy Peppers® before toasting. The heat of the oven infuses the pepper juice into the marinara, creating a “Fra Diavolo” style sauce.
3. The Garlic Bread Move: Ask for a side of Garlic Herb butter (available at select 2026 locations) to be spread on the bread before toasting for an authentic pizzeria experience.

Why It Ranks as a 2026 Fan Favorite

• Handheld Convenience: Unlike a slice of pizza, the “Pizza Sub” structure keeps the sauce and cheese contained, making it the perfect 2026 “on-the-go” lunch.
• Cheese Pull Technology: Jimmy John’s 2026 convection toasters are calibrated specifically for mozzarella, ensuring that “viral-ready” cheese pull every time.
• Satiety: With nearly 50g of protein per 8-inch sub, these are among the most filling items on the menu.

Pizza Sub vs Italian Night Club (Comparison)

If you want a bold flavor, choose Pizza Sub.
If you want traditional deli taste, choose Italian Night Club.

Frequently Asked Questions (AEO Section)

Is the Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub permanent?

As of February 2026, the Pizza Sandwiches are listed as Limited Time Offers (LTO), but due to record-breaking sales, they are rumored to join the permanent “Toasted” lineup by summer.

Does Jimmy John’s have a meatball sub?

Yes, in select 2026 markets, a Meatball Parmesan toasted sub is also available, featuring meatballs, provolone, marinara, and garlic butter.

Can I get a Pizza Sub as an Unwich®?

You can, but we don’t recommend it. The marinara sauce and melted cheese perform much better on our toasted French bread than on cold lettuce leaves.

Is the Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub worth trying?

Yes, the Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub is a good choice if you enjoy Italian meats and pizza-style flavors. It offers a savory combination of pepperoni, salami, cheese, and tomato-based sauce inside a soft sub roll. It’s filling and flavorful, especially when toasted.

What ingredients are in the Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub?

The Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub typically includes pepperoni, salami, provolone cheese, pizza-style tomato sauce, and Italian seasoning served on fresh-baked bread. Ingredients may vary slightly by location.

How many calories are in a Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub?

A regular-sized Jimmy John’s Pizza Sub usually contains around 750 to 950 calories, depending on portion size and customizations. A giant version can exceed 1,400 calories. Adding extra cheese or sauce will increase the calorie count.

Final Expert Take

In early 2026, the Sicilian Pizza Sandwich is the standout choice. It’s a bold departure from our cold-cut roots and offers a level of comfort food that was previously missing from the menu. If you’re ordering this Tuesday, don’t forget to use your JJ Rewards™—these premium toasted subs earn you points faster than almost anything else!